Harry Shum Jr. Eliminated From DWTS Despite Two Perfect Scores — Fans Say the Voting Is Broken

Harry Shum Jr.'s DWTS elimination shocked fans: he scored a perfect 60/60 in the semifinals yet went home. See the scores and the Naya Rivera tribute.

Never miss a story — add CelebWatch to your Google preferred sources
Harry Shum Jr. smiling at a panel
Key Facts

Key Facts: Harry Shum Jr DWTS elimination

Key Facts: Harry Shum Jr DWTS elimination

  • What: Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson were eliminated in the Dancing With the Stars season 35 semifinals on Tuesday, November 17, 2026.
  • The shock: The pair scored a perfect 60 out of 60 across two dances, tied for the top of the judges’ leaderboard, and still went home.
  • Why: DWTS combines judges’ scores with viewer votes, and the lowest combined total goes home.
  • What’s next: The five remaining couples compete in a three-hour season finale on Tuesday, November 24, on ABC and Disney+.

The Harry Shum Jr DWTS elimination stunned viewers on Tuesday night. The Glee and Grey’s Anatomy star earned two perfect scores in the semifinals, yet he still went home one week before the finale. So how does a frontrunner with a flawless night miss the finale? The answer lies in the voting system.

Harry Shum Jr DWTS elimination: how a perfect 60 still sent him home

Six couples took the floor for the semifinals, each performing twice: once in a ballroom style and once in Latin. Shum and Johnson opened with a paso doble to Rihanna’s “We Found Love.” Judges Derek Hough, Carrie Ann Inaba, and Bruno Tonioli each gave them a 10, so the dance scored a perfect 30. Their quickstep to the Glee version of “Valerie” also earned three 10s, so the pair finished the night with 60 out of 60. Only Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov matched them. But judges’ scores are only half the result. Viewer votes make up the rest, and the combined total sent Shum and Johnson home.

Here is the full semifinal leaderboard:

CoupleDance 1Dance 2TotalResult
Harry Shum Jr. & Jenna Johnson303060Eliminated
Amber Glenn & Pasha Pashkov303060Finalist
Maura Higgins & Mark Ballas302959Finalist
Ezra Frech & Daniella Karagach273057Finalist
Tatyana Ali & Jan Ravnik272855Finalist
Connor Wood & Rylee Arnold242448Finalist

The Naya Rivera tribute that stole the night

Shum’s second dance carried extra weight: the quickstep to “Valerie” used the Glee version of the song as a tribute to his late Glee co-star Naya Rivera.

“Man, we are so proud of our dances,” Shum said in an Instagram Reel. “I hope all you Gleeks are happy with our dance.”

Naya Rivera smiling at a fan event panel in 2010

Naya Rivera at a 2010 fan event. Photo: Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Shum played Mike Chang on the Fox musical for all six seasons, and Rivera played Santana Lopez. In addition, his quickstep turned a competition dance into a goodbye to a friend.

Why fans say the DWTS voting system is broken

The result sparked an instant backlash online: the joint leaderboard leaders went home while the last-place couple stayed.

The math explains the twist: judges’ scores convert into leaderboard points, and the viewer vote converts into a second set of points. A low-ranked couple can still survive with a huge fan vote. For example, TV Insider’s analysis of the semifinal results suggests Wood must have earned the most viewer votes of all six couples to stay in over Shum. As a result, fans are calling for voting changes.

It was also the second stunning elimination in two weeks: Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy went home on Grammy Night despite strong scores. We covered that shock exit and the Maren Morris backlash here. The twist stung more for Johnson, because Chmerkovskiy is her husband.

“We’ll have our own finale”: what Harry and Jenna said next

Shum took the result in stride. Backstage, he told E! News he felt at “ease” with the elimination: “I kind of felt like we accomplished everything we wanted to.” He also hinted fans have not seen the last of the partnership: “I think we’ll have our own finale in some sort of way, shape or form in the future.”

Johnson shared her own heartbreak over their planned finale freestyle. “That’s the part that I’m most heartbroken about,” she told E!. “We had concocted this incredible journey that the ballroom won’t see this time. But maybe we’ll put it out there somewhere.”

Who is left in the DWTS season 35 finale?

Five couples will compete for the Len Goodman Mirrorball Trophy on Tuesday, November 24. Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov lead the field. Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas follow at 59 points. Ezra Frech, Tatyana Ali, and Connor Wood round out the final five with their partners.

The finale is a three-hour live telecast from 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. ET on ABC and Disney+, streaming the next day on Hulu. Judge Derek Hough returns with Carrie Ann Inaba and Bruno Tonioli. Earlier exits this season included Ciara Miller, who went home on Mariah Carey Night.

What’s next for Harry Shum Jr.?

Shum returns to Grey’s Anatomy as Dr. Benson Kwan, a role he has played since 2022. Before that, he spent six seasons as Mike Chang on Glee and led Shadowhunters as Magnus Bane.

Harry Shum Jr. at a Glee panel at Comic-Con

Harry Shum Jr. at a Glee panel. Photo: Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

Finally, fans are watching his social media for the freestyle he and Johnson may still share.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *