Justine Lupe Says Shep Rose and Taylor Ann Green Should Get Married — But Shep Just Pumped the Brakes

Justine Lupe says Shep Rose Taylor Ann Green should get married — but Shep told Bravo he would not propose "right now." Here is where the exes stand.

Never miss a story — add CelebWatch to your Google preferred sources
Justine Lupe at the 2024 Primetime Emmy Awards
Key Facts

Shep Rose Taylor Ann Green wedding bells? Not so fast. Justine Lupe thinks the Southern Charm exes should get married. She said so on Watch What Happens Live on November 12. But Shep himself pumped the brakes just weeks ago. So where do the former couple really stand? Here is the full picture.

Key Facts

  • What happened: Justine Lupe said on Watch What Happens Live (November 12) that Shep Rose and Taylor Ann Green should get married.
  • The catch: Shep told Bravo weeks earlier that he would not propose to Taylor “right now.”
  • Where to watch: Southern Charm Season 12 premiered November 12 on Bravo, with new episodes streaming the next day on Peacock.
  • Their history: Shep and Taylor dated for two years before splitting in 2022. They reconnected this summer.

Shep Rose Taylor Ann Green wedding bells? Not so fast. Justine Lupe thinks the Southern Charm exes should get married. She said so on Watch What Happens Live on November 12. But Shep himself pumped the brakes just weeks ago. So where do the former couple really stand? Here is the full picture.

Lupe appeared on the Bravo late-night show with Southern Charm star Craig Conover. The Nobody Wants This actress shared her Bravo hot takes in a rapid-fire segment, and her verdict on Shep and Taylor was clear: they should tie the knot. The show’s After Show kept the conversation going, with Craig facing questions about whether Shep and Taylor are really back together.

What Justine Lupe Said About Shep Rose and Taylor Ann Green

Lupe plays Morgan, the dry-witted sister, on Netflix’s Nobody Wants This. She stopped by the Clubhouse to promote the show’s third season. However, her Bravo opinions stole the spotlight. Bravo’s own description says she explained why she thinks Shep Rose and Taylor Ann Green should get married. She also weighed in on Austen Kroll and Salley Carson, and on whether Craig should take Hollywood by storm with his acting.

Lupe is far from the only person rooting for a Shep and Taylor reunion. Fans have shipped the pair for years. They dated for two years before their 2022 split, and Taylor then stepped away from Southern Charm after Season 10. But her return for Season 12 has put their story back at the center of the show. As a result, every comment about them now lands like a verdict.

Justine Lupe smiling at the 2024 Primetime Emmy Awards
Justine Lupe at the 2024 Primetime Emmy Awards. Photo: Max, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Shep Rose’s Answer: “Right Now? Not Right Now”

Shep, however, is not rushing toward the altar. At Bravo Fan Fest 2026, his former fling Molly O’Connell said he is “getting ready” for marriage and “wants to settle down.” But during the Battle of the Bravolebs panel, Shep opened up about his future with Taylor. Asked if he would propose to her today, his answer was blunt: “Right now? Not right now.”

He also explained why he wants to slow things down. “She, I think everyone knows, went through a toxic relationship, and I’m glad that it ended for a lot of reasons,” he said during the panel. “Mostly because I was able to make her laugh again, which is something that I’ve always enjoyed. You need time to heal. You need time to process. I think jumping back in is maybe a little dangerous.”

Meanwhile, Shep has stayed coy about whether a romantic reunion is on the table at all. In an interview with Us Weekly in October, he said he and Taylor spoke on the phone for 45 minutes the day before. “She knows we both really appreciate each other, and we are laughing about the past, and I’m really happy at the moment with our relationship,” he said. Asked directly about a reconciliation, he smiled and said, “You’re going to have to find out, darling.”

Andy Cohen, host of Watch What Happens Live
Andy Cohen hosts Watch What Happens Live, where Justine Lupe shared her take on Shep and Taylor. Photo: Digitas Photos, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Shep Rose Taylor Ann Green: A Timeline

The story stretches back years. So here is how Shep and Taylor got to this moment.

WhenWhat happened
2020–2022Shep and Taylor date for two years. They split in 2022. Shep later admits he cheated during the relationship.
2023Taylor begins dating Gaston Rojas. Her friendship with Shep turns strained, and she blocks his number at one point.
June 2026Taylor confirms her split from Gaston. She denies rumors that she and Shep have already rekindled their romance.
Summer 2026Shep and Taylor reconnect. They are spotted filming together, and they share dog playdates with her dog Penny and his dog Lil’ Craig.
October 18, 2026The exes talk on the phone for 45 minutes, Shep tells Us Weekly.
October 24–28, 2026At Bravo Fan Fest, Shep says he would not propose to Taylor “right now.” Bravo later publishes his full interview.
November 12, 2026Southern Charm Season 12 premieres on Bravo. The same night, Justine Lupe says on Watch What Happens Live that the pair should get married.

What Happens Next on Southern Charm Season 12

Season 12 premiered on Thursday, November 12, at 9 p.m. ET on Bravo, with new episodes streaming the next day on Peacock. The season puts Shep and Taylor’s reunion front and center. The trailer shows Taylor texting her ex out of the blue, then catches their reunion dinner, where she greets him with a simple “Hi, stranger.”

Bravo’s season announcement says Shep is “working on bettering himself, but is forced to confront some harsh realities after ‘the one that got away’ reemerges.” Taylor, meanwhile, “surprises both Shep and the group of friends when she texts her ex-boyfriend out of the blue.” So the show will answer the question Lupe raised, one episode at a time.

Craig Conover, for his part, is not buying the fairy tale yet. In the trailer, he calls Shep “delusional” about marrying Taylor while still hooking up with other women. That tension will likely drive much of the season, since Southern Charm has always thrived on the gap between what its stars say and what they do.

The Charleston, South Carolina skyline seen from the harbor
Charleston, South Carolina, the home of Southern Charm. Photo: Animum, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Why Fans Are So Invested in Shep Rose Taylor Ann Green

First, this is a second-chance story, and Bravo fans love those. Shep is the show’s original bachelor, and Taylor is the one who got away. Their split was messy, and both have said so publicly. Now they are older, and they seem to actually enjoy each other’s company again. That combination is catnip for reality TV viewers.

Second, the timing is perfect. Taylor also popped up on Below Deck Season 13, so Bravo is clearly keeping her in the family. And Southern Charm remains one of the network’s longest-running hits. For Bravo stars, a big season can turn reality fame into a full-time career, and the pay varies wildly across franchises. A Shep and Taylor wedding storyline would be ratings gold.

Finally, the debate itself is the entertainment. Lupe says marry. Shep says not right now. Craig says delusional. Taylor, so far, has said little at all. As a result, fans will keep watching to see who is right. For more reality TV reunion drama, our Love Is Blind Season 11 deleted scenes breakdown shows how one unaired moment can rewrite a whole breakup. And our Below Deck cast guide tracks where Taylor’s fellow Bravo stars ended up.

The bottom line is simple. Justine Lupe gave the former couple her blessing. Shep gave them time instead. Whether that time leads to a proposal, or to another goodbye, will play out on Southern Charm Season 12. Watch this space.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *